Elderly Couple Sue Art Dealer After African Mask They Sold Him For $158 Was Later Auctioned For $4.4 Million

An elderly couple is suing an art dealer after they sold an African face mask for $158 that went on to fetch millions of dollars.

Getty Images

In 2021, while cleaning out their property, the anonymous couple from Nîmes, France, decided to sell the peculiar mask to a nearby supplier.

They sold it for $158 to a trader known as "Mr. Z" in September of that year, and he went on to profit millions from it.

A few months later, at an auction in Montpellier, Mr. Z sold the artwork, a traditional Fang mask from Gabon used at weddings, funerals, and other rituals, for an incredible $4.4 million.

The French couple, who are 81 and 88 years old, were unaware of the item's rarity until reading about Mr. Z's successful sale in the newspaper.

Getty Images

ARTnews reports that the husband's grandfather, a former colonial ruler of Africa, brought the Fang mask to France.

Now because they think Mr. Z cheated them, they are suing him.

The dispute has been going on for some time, and on June 28, the Nîmes Court of Appeals decided that their complaint 'appears to be well-founded in principle.'

As a result, the sale proceeds have been frozen while the case is still pending, according to Artnet News.

The unhappy couple has claimed that Mr. Z was aware of the face mask's actual value before purchasing it from them for 0.00359090909 percent of the amount it was ultimately sold for.

When Mr. Z sought professional guidance, the rare mask—which is believed to have originated in the 19th century—was originally valued between $317,416 (€300,000) and $423,222(€400,000).

Regarding its rarity, Artnet News was able to get court documents that stated: "This piece of kaolin-coated cheese wood is therefore exceptional in terms of its rarity, as only a dozen or so other reference specimens are known to exist worldwide, in Western museums and collection."

In light of their complaint, the dealer reportedly offered the French couple $317,416(€300,000) in compensation; nevertheless, they turned down his offer.

Getty Images

Mr. Z is "a second-hand dealer and not an antique dealer and cannot be considered a valuation professional," according to their attorney.

They went on, "He has no knowledge of African art."

Their case is still pending and will stay that way until a decision is made.

There are indications that it is presently being examined by a higher court in Nîmes.

While art can be a source of beauty and cultural exchange, it can also become a source of conflict and controversy.

This case will ultimately help shape the future of art dealings, emphasizing the importance of transparency, fairness, and ethical conduct in preserving cultural heritage and promoting justice in the art market.

The elderly couple's pursuit of justice may set a precedent for similar cases and reaffirm the significance of valuing cultural artifacts beyond their financial worth.